Our Story

Small-batch cookies, baked by hand for our northern Indiana neighbors.

At Caudill Cookie Co., every cookie begins the same way it always has — in Katie's kitchen, made by hand, one small batch at a time. What started as a love of baking has grown into a simple promise to our community: real ingredients, no shortcuts, and treats worth coming back for.

Our signature homemade Oreo cookie wasn't rushed to market. Katie tested, tweaked, and tasted it until it earned its name — richer, fresher, and more satisfying than anything else around. Her sugar cookies have won the same devotion: soft, buttery, and made to bring a little something special to your table.

We believe great cookies are meant to be shared — at the kitchen table, the church potluck, the school fundraiser, and every small celebration in between. That's why we keep things personal and bake fresh to order, adding a new recipe to the menu only once it's truly ready.

Proudly baked for our neighbors across northern Indiana — one homemade cookie at a time.